How Automation Is Making Websites Generic

What you’ll learn: How automation transforms website development, why over-reliance on tools can lead to generic, undifferentiated sites, and how working with real experts at Baumbach Solutions ensures a tailored, high-impact online presence.

Intro

Automation and AI-driven builders let you spin up websites in minutes. That speed can be a game-changer for solopreneurs and small businesses—but it also risks churning out sites that all start to look the same. In this post, we’ll explore how to leverage automation without sacrificing the unique character and effectiveness only skilled designers can deliver.

1. The Rise of Automation in Website Development

In recent years, platforms like Wix ADI, Squarespace’s LayoutEngine, and AI-driven WordPress plugins have dramatically lowered the barrier to entry. You can answer a few prompts, and an entire site scaffolds itself in seconds.

A local salon owner used an AI site builder to launch her booking site. Within days, she spotted three competitors with nearly identical layouts, navigation, and imagery.

Why it matters Generic designs fail to capture your brand’s voice. Visitors can’t distinguish you from dozens of similar sites. Stat: By 2025, 78% of companies worldwide have adopted AI technologies in at least one business function  Action Tips: Use automated builders for rapid prototyping, not the final design. Layer in your own brand assets (fonts, color codes, imagery). Reserve custom copy and SEO work for page-specific sections. Potential Pitfalls: Over-trimming development time can leave SEO gaps. Blind reliance on stock imagery may dilute authenticity.

Generic website templates displayed on a computer screen
Avoid one-size-fits-all templates that dilute your brand presence.

2. Why Automation Tends Toward Generic Sites

Most builders rely on a finite library of templates, pre-written copy blocks, and AI-recommended layouts. The result? Your site can end up blending in rather than standing out.

A neighborhood bakery swapped to an AI-generated template. A week later, they realized their competitor’s site used the same hero image and text blocks—undermining both brands.

Why it matters Lack of differentiation makes competing on price inevitable. Uniform user journeys ignore your customers’ unique needs. Stat: As of June 2025, WordPress powers 43.5% of all websites, many on identical themes  Action Tips: Audit template code to ensure unique class names and styles. Customize page layouts beyond the default grid. Write original headlines—don’t lean on AI’s first suggestions. Potential Pitfalls: High customization without expert oversight can break responsive design. Ignoring accessibility checks in templated code risks compliance issues.

Split-screen showing two nearly identical generic bakery website templates
When every site looks the same, you lose the trust that comes from a distinctive brand.

3. How Baumbach Solutions Helps

At Baumbach Solutions, we pair automation with deep design and development expertise. We treat AI builders as accelerators, not shortcuts—integrating them into a custom workflow that preserves your brand’s soul.

One legal firm went from a 1.2% conversion rate on a stock template to 4.8% after we re-architected their site with tailored content blocks and performance optimizations.

Why it matters Custom code and strategic design boost engagement and conversions. Expert oversight catches SEO and UX blind spots that tools miss. Stat: Industry data shows custom sites average 2–5× higher conversion rates than template-based sites in the same sector  Action Tips: Begin every project with a brand-discovery workshop. Use AI to draft initial wireframes, then iterate with real designers. Conduct A/B tests on critical pages to validate automated suggestions. Potential Pitfalls: Neglecting ongoing maintenance means your “custom” site can drift back toward generic. Over-automation of content updates can erode SEO quality over time.

A web designer from Baumbach Solutions customizing an AI-generated website template to match a client’s branding
Skilled craftsmanship turns automation’s raw potential into a unique, results-driven site.

Final Thoughts

Automation is a powerful tool—but it’s just one part of the equation. When you combine speed with human expertise, you get websites that not only launch fast but also resonate deeply, rank higher, and convert better.

Next Steps/Resources

Audit your current site for generic patterns. Schedule a free brand-discovery call with Baumbach Solutions. Download our “Customization Checklist for AI-Built Sites.”

Want to see this for your business?

👉 Get a Quote or call 608-387-8998